![]() |
| image: Markus Spiske on Unsplash |
In 1897, the first cents-off grocery coupon was introduced, and shopping changed forever. C.W. Post had just introduced his breakfast cereal Grape-Nuts. In efforts to entice housewives to try this cereal out on their families, Post issued a 1-cent off coupon for a 15-cent box of cereal. The coupon promotion was a massive success. Folks who had never tasted a cold breakfast cereal gave Grape-Nuts a shot. Not only did the shopping change, but what Americans ate for breakfast also changed. By 1900, Battle Creek, Michigan had become the center of the "cereal rush."
In the 1960s, my mother was a young wife and mother. My father's career had had a rocky start. Like many young couples of the time, money was always tight. My mother had a small allowance for groceries each week, but she worked hard to make it stretch. She planned meals around traditional budget foods and she clipped coupons. In my memory, I can still see the stiff coupons that she'd pull out of the Reader's Digest magazine. These coupons had computer punch-outs that could be read by machines. Brands like Proctor & Gamble, Hills Bros., and Heinz used these "space-age" coupons. My mother also clipped coupons from the newspaper and magazines.
On shopping day, she had her stack of coupons, her list, and a small amount of cash. My mother, like many other women of the time, was loyal to one store. she didn't shop several stores per week. She didn't even shop multiple days at the same store in a week. There was no stopping by the store while running errands and picking up extras of quantity-limited, loss leader sale items. She shopped once per week at a single store. In the early years of their marriage, my parents had one car. It was primarily for my father to get to work. But on shopping day, my mother would drive him, then have the car for her shopping. For many American families, this was standard in the late 1950s and much of the 1960s. When my parents could finally afford a second car, my mother's shopping methods were pretty well-cemented into her routine.
Did she save a lot of money with coupons? I remember what now seems like strange amounts on the coupons -- 7 cents off, 13 cents off, etc. Each week she had a stack of about 5 coupons to use. If the average value was about 10 cents off, she saved about 50 cents. To us today, a savings of 50 cents doesn't sound like very much. For her budget in the 1960s, a 50-cent savings added an extra box of cereal or a pound of ground beef for the family for the week. In 1965, according to the USDA, the average grocery bill for a family of 4 averaged between $20 and $35 per week. In that low amount, you can understand how valuable a 50-cent savings might be.
My mother had very few options for saving money on groceries. There were no price-tracking apps, no online shopping, no warehouse clubs, and in many instances, just one market within a reasonable drive from a person's home. Clipping paper coupons and cooking inexpensive staples from scratch were the only levers a homemaker could pull to reduce her grocery bill.
The modern shopper is truly fortunate. We have so many options for saving big on groceries. I know there are several friends here who love the bulk deals they get at Costco and Sam's Club. And I know there are a few who love the thrill of the deal chase, stacking coupons, loss-leaders, and rebates. And many of us are frequent digital coupon shoppers. I'll tell you what was a real discount shopping game-changer for me. In 2020, I discovered you could order food, ordinary food like cans of tuna, online to be shipped to your home.
As you can see, we're not locked into one main method of saving money on our grocery purchases.
Coupons, themselves, have changed. I do occasionally get high-value coupons in the mail. Most recently I got a $10 off coupon for Fred Meyer. But that's about it for paper coupons for me. In fact, it's not just me, but paper coupons have dropped sharply in both circulation and frequency of use in the last decade. Where you do see paper coupons are the Catalina checkout printers that spit out targeted coupons to shoppers as they pay for their groceries and the on-pack "peelies" stuck to the front of a packaged food item.
Where are the coupons today? They're mostly found in digital store apps, the load-to-card coupons.
I have mixed feelings about the digital coupons. On the one hand, you can often buy multiples of the couponed item with a single coupon. Sometimes you can buy 5 or 6 of the same item using that one loaded coupon. You also don't have to sit at the kitchen table cutting coupons, sorting them, storing them, then going through them each week to pull out expired ones.
On the other hand, if you're not really tech savvy, loading digital coupons can be a pain. I'll give you a real life example. My phone is an older model and runs on an outdated operating system. It's a headache to load a digital coupon onto it. About 10 days ago, I was using that $10 off coupon at Fred Meyer. I walked past the milk coolers to see if they had any deals on milk. I used to find really great clearance markdowns on milk there years ago. This week, there were no clearance jugs of milk, but there was a great digital coupon for milk. It was almost half what I pay at WinCo for milk. But it required loading the digital coupon. I stood there working on my phone for about 8 or 9 minutes trying to get the coupon to load. It was frustrating, and I almost gave up. In my mind I was saying, "some savings just aren't worth the work." But then, like magic, I finally was able to get the coupon to load, and I bought 2 gallons of milk at a hefty savings.
If the item I was trying to save money on hadn't been a perishable product, but had been a pantry staple instead, I might have given up. I can buy pantry staples at a discount in so many other ways. I can shop salvage stores, discount grocery stores, online, or in a restaurant supply for foods that don't require refrigeration at point of sale. I don't need to spend 9 frustrating minutes trying to score a deal on those foods.
Here's another real life, recent shopping example. I was at Walmart 2 weeks ago. I buy a favorite instant coffee there. That day it happened to be marked down more than a dollar per jar. However, they only had 2 jars left. This wasn't a roll-back markdown, but looked more like the product was being phased out. I bought the last 2 jars. And then once I got home I went onto Walmart.com to see if they listed the same discounted price and if they had any inventory. Well yes, the price was the same, and they had inventory. I ordered 10 jars. Because I spent more than the minimum order amount, they shipped it to me for free. While I was alarmed in the store to only find 2 jars and the type of shelf tag that is consistent with Walmart no longer carrying a specific item, ordering the 10 additional jars was a breeze. I probably spent the same 8 or 9 minutes doing the online order, but these weren't stressful 8-9 minutes. Shopping online in this instance was a lot more relaxed than buying the milk at Fred Meyer that one day.
I guess what I'm getting at is that today couponing is sometimes beneficial, and maybe the only way you can make great savings on a specific product, but we have other methods of saving on groceries that our mothers didn't have. For me, digital coupons loaded in the store are a real frustration and only valuable if I don't have other avenues for getting that same great deal. I can't order jugs of milk to be shipped to me. Ditto with cheese (another digital coupon that I'm willing to spend 10 minutes loading onto my phone). I will stretch my patience with digital coupons in those instances. In reality, I saved about $2.50 on those gallons of milk and spent less than 10 hands-on minutes. That's an hourly wage of $15 per hour's work, if I had spent the whole hour loading coupon after coupon with similar savings. I have to admit, that's a nice hourly wage I earned.
When a coupon doesn't exist for an item I want, I can often use another method to save on it. I have so many grocery procurement options, and often I can save more than a manufacturer coupon can offer.
I will say that for some people, saving with coupons feels like a game. And I believe there is value in that. If a part of your work feels like a game to you, it makes doing the mundane an interesting task instead of an obligation. But if modern coupons aren't easy for you, for whatever reason, take heart, we have other options for saving on our weekly needs.
How do you feel about modern coupons? Do you have a source of paper coupons (newspaper insert, mailers)? Is using coupons a part of your strategy to reduce your household's costs? There's no right or wrong answer here. Share your recent experiences with coupons or other ways you prefer to save on groceries in the comments.
