As we get older, doesn't it seem like we need to work harder to maintain good health?
This has been a process for my family, taking place over several years. All of the fruits and vegetables that we eat are not only to save money or crowd out other foods. We've made a deliberate move to obtain our vitamins and minerals primarily through the foods we eat.
Years ago, we took once per day type vitamins to ensure we were covering our bases with nutrients. At that time, we typically had 3 to 4 servings of produce each day. That's how my family ate as I was growing up. And we all took a vitamin pill each day.
The problem I see with relying on a vitamin pill is there may be other nutrients that the pill lacks but that would be found in whole foods. In addition, some experts believe that food sources of nutrients may be better absorbed by the body than those in supplement form.
I do take a couple of supplements, Vitamin D with K and B-Complex, plus a couple of supplements that target specific needs. However, in general, we try to maximize our consumption of nutrient-dense foods while minimizing the weaker foods.
You may have noticed on last night's dinner plate I had 3 servings of vegetables/fruits, a kale and cranberry salad, roasted pumpkin cubes, and fresh tomato wedges. Earlier in the day I had a smoothie that had 2 servings of fruits/vegetables for breakfast and a garden salad plus fresh fruit with my lunch. That brought me up to 7 servings of fruits and vegetables for the day. That's about where we like to be with our produce consumption. To get there, I do rely on some fruit/vegetable powders in my smoothies, hence the purchase of greens powder on my shopping for the month.
There was a study published about a year ago by the NIH that found a decline in nutritional value for many foods over the past several decades, due to farming practices, selection of cultivars, and reduced nutritional and microbial content of soils. This is a global problem and not one solely in the US or the West.
This means today's populations should be eating more of the nutrient-dense foods than previously customary to maintain good health.
Variety and quality in meat and poultry cuts
It's not just fruits and vegetables, but my husband and I are also focusing on high quality protein, good fats, and whole grains or other complex carbohydrate foods.
I've talked about our beef deliveries direct from a rancher. Not only does this financially help an individual and his family and keep a family-owned ranch in business, but I believe the meat may be more nutritious than what I might have bought at the supermarket. Factory-farmed animals often are solely grain-fed and confined on tightly packed lots. This type of farming reduces mineral and amino acid content of the meat and changes the ratio of omega-3s to omega-6s.
In addition, when I would previously buy meat at the store, I would only buy what was least expensive, which tended to be either ground or specific cuts, over and over. By buying our beef as we do, we get a variety of cuts, some with bones and some with more fat than others. I used to only buy boneless beef. Now, with receiving beef with the bones, I use the bones to make broth, yielding even more nutrients for our consumption. I also render any fatty portions to use in cooking later. Years ago, I was particularly interested in the zinc and iron content of beef and was surprised to find that different cuts contained different amounts of those minerals.
I've also returned to buying whole chickens instead of parts or boneless/skinless. Like with the beef, different parts of the chicken contain different levels of some nutrients, so having a whole chicken forces us to eat both dark and light meat. I also use the bones from the whole bird to make chicken stock. You know what I never buy any more? Beef or chicken bouillon cubes or powder.
While I miss the more convenient chicken parts or boneless/skinless pieces compared to whole, this trade off for nutrients is important for my family. I've mentioned that we found a grocery store chicken that we really like, Just Bare. For the time being, we feel this is a good compromise for quality vs price. The chickens are raised without use of antibiotics and are not kept in cages. We found the cooked texture and taste to be better for this brand compared to the cheaper brands in the store.
Diversifying fats and introducing new ones
As for changing the fats that we consume, the last couple of Christmases I've requested bottles of olive oil or avocado oil as gifts. We are trying to use more of those oils for salads and some cooking. We have significantly reduced our use of all-purpose vegetable oils, which are heavily processed. We used to go through a gallon of the cheapest vegetable oil every two months. With our change in the fats that we use in cooking and baking, this last gallon of vegetable oil has lasted for 3 months so far, and is still going strong. I've mentioned many times that we use "rescued" meat fat, saved from the meat that we buy. We also use coconut oil, butter, and the above mentioned avocado and olive oils.
I'm old enough to remember when butter was considered bad and margarine was the "savior" spreadable fat. My parents tried for years to get my grandmother to give up her butter. And then in the 90s, it became known that trans fats were actually the bad ones. I also remember coconut oil being a villain in the fat world. And now that thinking has been reversed. So my family's decision has been to use a wide variety of natural oils and fats in our diet and diversify our risks, so to speak.
This fall I plan on clarifying some of the beef fat I've saved in the freezer. I'll try baking with this in pie pastry. I've clarified bacon fat for pie pastry with good results, so I'm hopeful that beef fat will also make a good pie crust. Clarifying animal fat is simply a process of boiling fat in water, chilling, then removing the fat. This reduces the meaty flavor of the fat and makes it suitable, flavor wise, for baking. It also removes any browned herb or meat bits from the fat. I'll let you know what we think of using clarified beef fat in baking.
So, when you see my family making purchasing choices for more expensive groceries than we used to (and driving our grocery spending up), it's a deliberate attempt to maintain good health through improved nutrition as we get older.
Have you made any nutrition-based food changes over the years? Do you think better nutrition can lead to healthier aging?
Yes, absolutely to both your questions at the end! As mentioned previously, I'm working on my M.S. in Human Nutrition and Functional Medicine, which is an evidence-based program, meaning everything is backed by research. No "so and so thinks" or woo-woo stuff. Solid science, which was important to me. You are very much on the right track with your changes and thinking. Overall rate of all-cause mortality lowers by 7% with higher fruit and vegetable consumption but that increases to 30-something percent (don't remember exact number here) if those are low-pesticide fruits and vegetables. This could be organic, but also homegrown, or done by focusing on produce typically grown with less pesticides (focusing on the Clean 15 list, for example).
ReplyDeleteAnd yes, typical conventionally-grown produce often has less nutrition in the past, so this is where homegrown or regeneratively-grown produce shines, when the soil is cared for and enriched so everything grown in it is naturally more nutritious. Also, as you mentioned, picking more nutrient-dense choices. However, from what I have learned from some brilliant professors who know way more than I do about this, I'm not sure that we can any longer fully get everything we need from just food, though I personally consume 8-10 servings of a variety of fruits and vegetables most days. So I do still utilize a high quality multivitamin alongside. And then, taking into account personal genetic differences, some people simply need higher quantities of specific nutrients to begin with or do not process some variations well. I've had all of our family's DNA tested now (had done mine and my oldest's 14 years ago) since beginning this program in order to personalize our nutrition further. For instance, my genetics are such that I don't turn beta carotene into vitamin A well, so I need to get my vitamin A from a supplement or from food sources in that form. I need extra B12 due to genetic variations, and extra magnesium (which I had figured out from trial and error long before I knew why). My vitamin D receptors are not adequate, so I will always need high doses of D with K for optimum health. Higher levels of protein ensure that our body has all it needs not only for muscle, but for manufacturing the many enzymes need to work the way it should. My point being, we are in the age of being able to highly personalize and maximize our nutrition for optimum health and longevity. It's a fascinating science and I really enjoy the puzzle of helping friends and family (and soon, clients!) figure out THEIR best practices.
Anyhow, I could talk about this stuff all day, lol. But I'm proud of you for evolving your diet as you learn more and putting your health as a priority over sticking with the absolute lowest cost products.
Such interesting and good information, Cat. Would you consider doing posts here from time to time about nutrition? Where do you get genetically tested for nutrition? Was it expensive? Last year, I decided I could use a nutrition tune up and wanted to go to a nutritionist. My insurance would pay for it. However, I couldn't find one. I contacted several and not one of them called me back. :(
DeleteHear, hear, Live and Learn, Cat, and Lili! Great stuff on all accounts, and I would also love to hear more functional medicine nutritional perspective, since I personally believe (for a number of reasons) that functional medicine is what medicine was meant to be. Good luck in your studies, Cat! We've also done some of the research to try to tailor diet and supplements to the nutritional needs of our individual family members, and now believe that there are some important situations for careful supplementation, in addition to mindful cooking and eating. Lili, you know you're preaching to the choir with me, and I'm so proud of the ways you're finding to balance your finances and your health choices. And Live and Learn, isn't it FRUSTRATING how hard it is to find good help when you're ready and willing to buckle down and make some constructive changes? (sigh) Lots of people we know basically want the doc to hurry up and give them a pill for their cholesterol/blood sugar/etc, so they can get out to pick up fast food and/or fancy coffees on the way home; and I once had a very cynical doctor basically refuse to discuss possible diet and lifestyle improvements with me because they said, "No one ever sticks to them." (I finally found help from another source, and HAVE made them.) Great topic! Have a great day! Sara
DeleteLive and Learn,
DeleteThe genetic testing is not specific for nutrition. I had mine and my family's done through 23andMe and the requested a download of the raw data, which I've then run through various interpretation systems. With the recent buyout, I'm not sure that's the best choice out there these days, but it is certainly one of the lowest-cost ways to do this. One that comes highly recommended by some of my professors is 3 x 4 Genetics, but it also costs substantially more. Sites useful for applying this for a layperson could be those such as Gene Food (cost was around $89), or Dr. Lynch's version at Seeking Health. But some of the companies such as 3 x 4 Genetics provide a pretty in-depth analysis.
I'm sorry you haven't been able to find a nutritionist. Laws for this vary so much by state and I don't remember what state you are in. Here in Oklahoma, the designation for a Certified Nutrition Specialist isn't recognized, sadly (we are not very progressive), but, in for instance New Mexico, I can, after finishing my degree, get in 1000 supervised hours and pass a board exam for that license. So in my own state, I will have to work as a "nutrition coach" or some other educational role.
I hope this helps.
Cat
Sara,
DeleteGood for you on working on this for your own family! It's challenging at times but so worth it. How sad about that doctor's cynicism. :( Thanks for the well wishes!
Cat
Hi Cat,
DeleteThank you for providing all of this information. I checked the Clean 15 list, and of the produce that we buy, a lot of it is on that list (cabbage, carrots, watermelon, frozen peas, onions). Sadly, broccoli is not on the list. I was also surprised to find kale is on the Dirty Dozen list. My family are big kale fans. At least we mostly eat kale that we've grown in our garden. Your info gives me even more motivation to continue with our garden.
As you've modified your own food choices, have you noticed any health benefits? One of the things I've noticed with my own health is I haven't had a sustained headache in a couple of years, the kind that lasts all day or even a couple of days. I don't know if this is due to changes in my diet or post-menopause, but it's a welcome change for me. The other thing I've noticed is I don't crave processed food any more.
I've been told (by MDs) that most folks in the greater Seattle area are Vit D deficient and should be tested regularly for this hormone/vitamin. So, I'll likely take Vit D/K for life, here.
I'm wishing you much success as you complete your MS and then get some sort of certification to put this knowledge into practice for a career.
Hi Sara,
DeleteYou and I take similar approaches to our health. I, too, have had a couple of those unhelpful MD appointments, when I asked about natural changes or additions I could make. I don't think any of that is covered in traditional medical school. I've had situations where I had to do some of my own research and present the info to my doctor. It takes work to find the right medical practitioner. I'm so glad you've found good ones in the places you've lived.
That was me ^^^^ Sorry about that.
DeleteLili,
DeleteYes, I've definitely seen huge improvements in my health with dietary changes. While I'm in a formal degree program now, the joke in my household has been that I gave myself a Master's through reading and learning on my own previously. When our oldest daughter, now 25, was 6 months old, I was diagnosed with lupus (SLE). I had frequent migraines, joint pain (particularly in my hands and wrists), random periods of exhaustion, unexplained rashes, and more. In 2011, when our youngest was a baby, a thyroid nodule was found to be cancer during the removal surgery and Hashimoto's was also diagnosed due to the thyroid damage found. Anyway, bit by bit, small changes here and there added up, first getting rid of many processed foods, then vegetable oils, and then eventually finding out I had celiac and eliminating all gluten. The last few years, adding more and more produce, I feel better and better, and as you know, now am very active, including backpacking trips. Migraines are extremely rare for me, joint pain almost non-existent, I lift heavy weights at the gym regularly as well as walking, and take dance classes with my hubby (who has also noted many positive changes). Several friends have asked for my help and this inspired me to start back to school, first with a few prerequisites beginning in January 2024 and then jumping into my Master's program in October 2024. I am really enjoying (aside from paper writing!) learning in-depth about how nutrition affects health, both short-term and long-term.
Oh, and also, while broccoli isn't on the "clean 15" list, it's also not on the dirty dozen list, either. It falls somewhere in between. And eating a decent amount of produce at all (I believe in this study it was 4-5 servings daily, so not nearly what you and I aim for) reduced all-cause mortality by 7%. So I personally believe, based on this, that it's still better to eat that broccoli than not eat it. And if organic is affordable, you could go that route. https://www.ewg.org/foodnews/full-list.php
DeleteRemember when eggs were bad because of the cholesterol they contain? Now they are considered a good source of protein with an okay kind of cholesterol.
ReplyDeleteHi Live and Learn,
DeleteI remember that about eggs, too. There are "better" eggs now available in most supermarkets. The eggs my daughter brought home from her hen-sitting gig did seem better, harder and thicker shells with firmer yolks. I'm guessing pastured eggs are comparable to the eggs from our neighbor.
I enjoy seeing how everyone incorporates more healthy options in their diets. I tend to slack off and it is motivating to get a boost from these posts. Can I ask you where you purchase your greens powder from?
ReplyDeleteHi Ruthie,
DeleteThere are a couple of good ones out there. I look for ingredients that I would not normally add to my diet, like algae (chlorella and spirulina) and wheat grass and barley grass. It's also important to me to use a product that is all organic. And I look for a product that has been studied for benefits.
My favorite is Brickhouse Nutrition Field of Greens. I think its very good. It's pricey, so I wait for a holiday and stack deals. I buy directly from their website. My last purchase from them was Labor Day, and I think I may have saved 25%, plus bought a multi-pack and saved even more. I expect they'll have a Veteran's Day sale next month.
Do you have Grocery Outlet in your area? In the natural foods aisle, Grocery Outlet sometimes has greens and other vegetable powders. I get organic beet powder from there. There have some pretty good deals on vegetable powders, and are a great way to start in on doing a greens powder.I just looked up Grocery Outlet, and I don't think there is one in your area. Idaho and Nevada are the closest it looks like.
Vitamin Shoppe carries a couple of good ones on their website, too. If you check those out, look at the ingredients list. Some also contain probiotics, if that would be helpful for you. Amazing Grass is a good one at Vitamin Shoppe and not as expensive as Field of Greens. Amazing Grass is also sold in some grocery stores, like Fred Meyer (is that Smith's now?).
The brand Live It Up (on their website letsliveitup.com) Super Greens is also a highly rated greens powder. It's science-backed and 3rd party tested.
For myself, I steer clear of Amazon for supplements. If I find a brand I like, I go directly to that product's website, whenever possible
I hope this helps.